Step back out now, and watch the pieces work together.
Worked example: a note-taking app
Flow is intelligence in motion.
Our reading, not an axiom: This page puts the earlier steps in motion on one made-up sign-up.
Here's a full read of a sign-up that doesn't exist. The app, its screens and its clauses are made up for this page and don't describe any real company. The point is to show the reading, step by step, so you can do the same with the next sign-up in front of you.
Each finding says how we know it. In the text means we read it in the document. Their claim means the company says so somewhere we can't check. Not stated means the document is silent, which is a finding too.
Step 1: the sign-in screen
"Sign in with Google" · Example Notes wants to:
- Associate you with your personal info on Google
- See your primary Google Account email address
- See your personal info, including any personal info you've made publicly available
- View your email messages and settings
- See, edit, create, and delete all of your Google Drive files
Made-up screen. The permission wording matches Google's public descriptions.
- The first three are a normal sign-in. In the text
- "View your email messages and settings" means reading every email you have, including password resets. A note app has no reason to need it. In the text
- Full Drive access covers every file you have, not just notes. The narrow permission, "only the specific Google Drive files you use with this app," would do the job. In the text
- The app's site says mail access is "for smart reminders." Their claim
- Try it yourself: paste these lines into the scope decoder.
Step 2: the terms
Terms of Service (excerpt, made up)
4.2 You grant Example Notes a worldwide, perpetual, irrevocable and sublicensable license to your Content, including audio recordings of meetings.
4.3 We may use Content to train and improve our artificial intelligence features.
9.1 Disputes will be resolved by binding arbitration. You may opt out by emailing us within 30 days of sign-up.
11. We may modify these terms at any time.
- Meeting recordings carry your voice and other people's. Together, 4.2 and 4.3 let them keep the recordings forever, pass them on, and train on them. In the text
- No training opt-out anywhere in the terms. Not stated
- The arbitration opt-out is 30 days by email in this version. Check the window in the version you get. In the text
- Terms can change at any time, and they don't promise to email you first. Not stated
- The highlights are what the highlighter marks on this text.
Step 3: the privacy policy
Privacy Policy (excerpt, made up)
We do not sell your personal information. We share personal information with analytics and advertising partners.
After deletion we retain data in backups for a reasonable period.
- "We don't sell" followed straight away by sharing with advertisers. In the text
- "A reasonable period" isn't a number. How long backups last is unknown. Not stated
Step 4: the call
Triage readout for this made-up app
NO-GO: Stop here
Recordings are used for AI training with no opt-out, and the sign-in asks to read all your email. Either one is enough.
What we'd do instead
- Don't connect a main Google account. If you must try it, use a spare account with nothing in it.
- Ask the company in writing whether recordings are used for training and whether there's an opt-out. Keep the answer.
- If you already signed in, remove the app at myaccount.google.com/permissions, then send the arbitration opt-out inside the window if you want to keep that option.
- Look for a notes app whose sign-in asks for only your name and email.